“Dead
bodies. Dead of night. Broken glass. Debris everywhere. Vehicle 1, Vehicle 2.
Wreckage. Carnage. Saw and felt lots of things like…the dread.”
Jeff paused. His
face sagged, letting out a tired sigh.
Jeff was a policeman for 30 years. A traffic
homicide detective and sergeant of a CRU, Crash Reconstruction Unit for 11
years. This interview dredged up Jeff’s memories of the job, victims he got to
know (though dead) and the families that cared or did not care.
***
INTERVIEWER: How many crashes did you work?
Jeff: 86 fatals and maybe 3 times that in crashes.
You
walked up to a scene, what did you think and feel?
It started before that. Way before walking up to the
carnage. I’d mark out a couple blocks away. Prepare myself. My heart would be
pounding. Was anxious, really anxious. The dread, I’d be overwhelmed by it. Steeled
myself against the cold. Had to survive the moment so I could move beyond it. Get
back to my life. Home to the wife, the boys. I hardened. Calmed down.
Tell
me more about that dread…what was it about?
Many things. Drama. Pain. Didn’t want to deal with
it. Families, bureaucracy. The media. Flood of questions. The case. Painstakingly
picking up evidence. Hated that. Picking up small stupid shit, bagging possible
evidence.
The dread. Scared to fuck it up. I’d get closer to
the crash, observed from afar. I slowed down - looked to see the entire scene. Was
the scene protected or contaminated? Looked for evidence. Direction of travel. Placement
of vehicles. Played a movie in my head, watching cars roll and crash.
You
got to the scene. What would be going on around you? What did you do first?
Took my time getting out of the car. Always had a
pen, a small note pad in my hand. ALWAYS.
You
say that like it was significant?
That notepad protected me. I saved myself. Had to
look like I was figuring, ciphering. Examining kind of thing. Needed to look
serious, have the furrowed brow, you know. If someone approached and I wasn’t
ready for them, I’d look down at my notepad. Scribbled. I’d hold up my finger
so they wouldn’t interrupt. I wrote. So I could breathe. I was posturing, I
suppose.
What
did you scribble?
The date. Weather. A car model. Anything to buy
time. The duty officer (or in charge
guy) and I talked. He had a notepad. Protected himself. Had to save himself
too. When he talked, I didn’t write. Let him feel important. Allowing him to talk
bought me time. Listened. Nodded. Asked questions. Hmm, really? Over there? He
repeated, I repeated. Then, I started listening. Really listening. The machine
started. Fear subsided. Fell away. I could finally engage.
So
you got in that zone, the work mode. The fear and dread was gone. What were
your thoughts then?
Had to be systematically unsystematic. If rigid, I
paid. Made a mistake or missed something. I was on guard. I protected me. Fluid.
Had to be ready to decide. Gave directions. Managed. The other cops, they’d be young,
wide-eyed. They got caught up…didn’t want to fuck up as well. Some of those young
sergeants, they were babies. They think they knew what happened and they
surmised the crash wrong most of the time!
Scenes…bedlam. Total mayhem. Two fire trucks, five
cop cars, media. Upset, angry bystanders. Why weren’t we helping the kid? Why
was he still lying on the road? Why has the driver NOT been arrested? It’d take
a while to figure out. I’ve had over a hundred people on a scene. I’d walk away, get low. Hunker down to the road.
Watched that movie in my head. Figured out the first events. Sometimes it was
self-evident. Other times, had to figure it out. The guy ran off the road here
to the right. He overcorrected, came back to the road, struck the other car and
bounced like a billiard ball and redirected. I’d piece hard evidence together.
Formulated the events. I liked the
theorizing, being a detective. Uncovering. Unlayering.
The
victims, the dead, what about them? What were you thinking about them?
They’re dead. Who, what, when, where, why and how. I
profiled. It was the ultimate profiling. Thoughts went like this: Somebody was
drunk. Or everyone was drunk. I was tainted. But when I started to work the
investigation, the victims had to be faceless, raceless. Was bound by the creed.
I was entrusted to get the facts.
What’s
the creed?
Looking up…
“No
greater honor will ever be bestowed on an Officer or a more profound duty
imposed on him than when he is entrusted with the investigation of the death of
a human being. It is his duty to find the facts, regardless of color or creed,
without prejudice and to let no power on earth deter him from presenting these
facts to the court without regard to personality.” ~Anonymous~
Felt serious about it.
Back
to the victims. What was going on with them?
Most of the time, they were gone. If there was any viability,
any hope at all, they were taken to the hospital because it was a medical case.
If dead, truly beyond any hope at all, the bodies weren’t moved. It became a
homicide investigation.
What
did you do with the witnesses?
God, they were laborious. If it was manslaughter,
hit and run, whodunit, then witnesses had to stay. Woe to the cop who let my
witness go. Were the witnesses separated from each other? If not, hauled ass
and separated them. If these guys were left together, they’d change their
stories. Discounted or second guessed each other. I wanted, needed the purity
of what they saw. They were my check-off list. Validated what I was formulating
or invalidated it. Young people didn’t give a shit. Or had folks who could barely
hold it together. They were traumatized. Weepy. It was ghoulish what they saw,
you know, dismemberment…messy scene. It was surreal for them.
How
did you talk to them?
Interviewed them before the evidence got stale,
vanished. It was urgent to get to the essence. Calmed the witnesses so I could
manage them. When they were having a hard time remembering, I had the witnesses
close their eyes and watched their movie in slow motion. Got a lot more crucial
details out of women than men. Guys were mechanical and dry. Just before they left,
I asked them what small details stood out in their memory of the crash. You
would be surprised at what I got. Stuff like “The driver threw something out”.
I’d sweep the trees and find a beer can. Reasonable suspicion stuff, gave me an
additional layer to investigate.
If
the victims were taken to the hospital, were body parts sometimes missed and
left at the scene?
Yes.
Would
those parts be taken to the hospital?
Negative. What if the piece was NOT viable? You
couldn’t use it.
The
death notification. It was an awful part of your job.
Yeah. Tough. Had to.
How
long did the notification take?
As little as 15-20 minutes. Stuck around as long as
an hour or more. For families, it’s their first contact with true, harsh reality…loved
one is DEAD. Had to make sure they were ok.
How
did you break the news?
Had a patent speech. Went to the address. Asked to
come in. Asked to sit down. Sat. “Bob has been involved in a very serious crash
tonight. He was injured and his injuries were very severe. Unfortunately, he succumbed to his injuries.
He did not survive.” Most folks went ape
shit at this time.
You
did it just like THAT?
Look, the bottom line is this: every time you work a
crash and give a death notification a little piece of you DIES too. It
de-sensitizes you. It’s about protecting yourself. You can’t get pulled in or you’re a mess. The
job needs to get done. It’s business as usual.
How
many death notifications did you give?
Between 30 and 40. Went in twos. Had to be ready to
protect ourselves. Maybe. From family. Didn’t know…who, what to expect. Dreaded giving the death notification but had
to be ready for possible danger. Had NO idea what was waiting.
Danger
from their emotions?
You don’t know if they were dealing drugs out of the
house! You don’t know what guns they had! You don’t know who they were and how
they would react. They might be constrained or they puked, bashed walls, fell
down. They’ve grabbed my shirt and screamed:
“YOU’RE LYING! YOU’VE GOT THE WRONG PERSON!”
Family also came to me to be held. Comforted. Would
comfort and would watch my gun. At times had to stay. No way, couldn’t leave
them alone… in their pain. Waited till help
arrived.
Never knew what the reaction was going to be. It was
cultural too.
Different
cultures reacted differently?
Whites, Blacks, Latinos. They COULD.
Latinos didn’t let me in sometimes. I’ve had to give death notification at the
door and let it eat. Suspicious. Wanted you gone right away. They could be
tight-lipped. Had to pry information from them. Latinos hid so they could stay.
One case. Drunk Latino. Wrecked. Pregnant girlfriend.
She was bleeding from the head. The drunk was fine. He called his brother
nearby. They covered up. They scooped her up and holed up. She missed that
miracle hour of treatment. She died the next day. I attended her autopsy two
days later. Had a cracked skull. Saw the fetus. The baby was perfect. Fully
formed…I got angry on that one. They didn’t look out for her. Bastards.
Think about this. Latinos come here for a better
life. Guess what, some don’t get it. I worked dozens of pedestrian fatals.
Mostly drunk Latinos. Crossed the road wasted and got ran over. There was this
spot downtown. Two Latino bars across the street from each other. Worked AT
LEAST 20 pedestrian fatals there. The men would go back and forth the bars
crossing the street at night. Wham! Impact would be so hard. Bodies would fly
through the air and land on cars. One lady driver was an absolute mess. She
didn’t hit anyone but was driving by. TWO bodies “fell from the sky”. Bloodied
bodies landed on her car windshield. A couple of guys had crossed the street
together. She could barely talk.
These men came to America to live their dreams. They
get killed crossing a street. (shaking head) What a waste!
You
sound angry or did you feel sorry for them?
Both. Good, bad, indifferent. These Latinos came hoping
to live better, with dignity. Many of these men came from places back home with
no electricity, no running water. From the “mountains.” They lived in huts or hovels.
Illiterate in their own language. Hell, they could barely speak their own
language! Worked their ass off, sent money home. Latinos, they’re the hardest
working people. They came alone. Lived in basements with sectioned tiny spaces.
These guys couldn’t read. Had no one. Had nothing. They lived shitty lives.
They were lonely and had nothing to do. They worked. Drank. They died here,
drunk, on some dirty highway. It was a damn shame. So senseless.
So,
how did you notify their family back home?
For some of the victims, couldn’t. Tried to find out
their nationality. Guatemalan. Mexican. Ecuadorian. Contacted consulates. Gave
info I had. Sometimes, it was a wash. They couldn’t find out who they were. Nada.
No one to notify.
That’s
terrible. Unknown, unmourned. Go on.
The ones who had wives, families. I’d go see them. Still wasn’t easy. Women were nervous. Scared. Scared to see us at
the door. Some could barely speak English. So, they’re scared, in shock AND
they’re grieving. That’s a whole lot on them. Women wept softly, quietly.
Quietly?
Being quiet, meant NOT drawing attention. NOT getting
found out. Reassured them that I wasn’t there about their “status.” Lots couldn’t
speak a lick of English. It was three, four in the morning. I had to involve an
older child to translate to their mother.
You
gave death notifications to children! How could you?
Did it twice. Felt awful. Wasn’t right. There’s no
interpreter at three, four in the morning. Just spent hours on a scene. Didn’t
know what was ahead of me. You gotta remember, this was 20-25 years ago. The
teens were right there. Things were in motion. I, we, couldn’t turn around.
Couldn’t leave. They knew something bad had gone down. These kids would
actually become the parent. They translated. The expressions on their faces,
having to tell their mother. They were so upset too. It sucked.
You
also said “Blacks”.
(Carefully) Not “blacks.” Black male. Black female. African-Americans.
How
did African-Americans culturally react when you notified them?
I’m talking about when I went into the rougher neighborhoods.
Had to be on guard. Careful. Alert. Some
of the communities…were…troubled. Got calls all the time. THEY DON’T LIKE US.
The Police. We’d go in on calls, or just patrolled. Neighbors, bystanders, would
come up. Around us. Crowd us. Some watched. Others, hostile. No respect. Angry,
even smoldering. What do YOU want? What are you here for? Get out of here! Would
have to tell them to back off.
Weren’t
you scared?
No. That’s what they wanted. For you to be afraid. Get
out of the car and show no fear. They’ll
be less likely to fuck with you. Be matter of fact. Mind you, it goes both
ways. The cops have done it to themselves over the years.
I didn’t respond to their bullshit. Their questions.
Why should I talk to the bystanders? Fuck ‘em. I was there for the family. Now,
if they asked if they could help, I’d talk to them. I’m not saying it was like
that all the time. Times we’d come in. Bystanders, neighbors would come around.
We’d just say a few words. Calmed them. There’d be no trouble.
Now, dealing with the family. Never matter of fact.
Was completely different with them. Showed empathy. The black females, the
matriarchs. They’d be grief-stricken. They’d fall to the ground. Screaming and
crying.
ALL
black females?
No. Course not. What I’m trying to say is the
matriarch’s grief was everybody’s grief. They ruled the roost. The women were dramatic.
Loud. News spread quickly. When it was a death, the community genuinely cared.
Grieved. Weren’t hostile. Well, you might hear stuff like “So, what did YOU do
to help, officer?” but for the most part, they tended the family.
Whites?
Let me guess, you’re going to say they were dignified?
No. Most of the time, situations had less drama…
That’s
racist!
No, no. Not racist. It’s going into a KNOWN
dangerous and hostile neighborhood. Black, white, orange! For Christ sake, I’m
married to an Asian!
It’s what I’ve seen. What I’ve experienced. PUT YOUR
OWN DAMN TWIST ON IT! It’s my reality. I looked around me; I had to know my surroundings
in ALL situations at ALL times. Besides, let’s not be naïve. You want to
accuse? Talk racism? REMEMBER, IT CAN GO BOTH WAYS! I’ve been hated because I’m
white. A white policeman!
You have no idea.
Let’s move on.
(Silence)
Can
you give me details of one death notification that stood out?
Many stood out.
Can
you tell me about one?
Okay.
Lauren. Young girl. Early 20s. Seriously drunk.
Alcho/sensor read .34 or .36. Going too fast. Car rolled. She was ejected. Typical
story. She was busted up pretty bad. Thin, covered in tattoos. Guessed she was
probably a wild child. The car had baby toys. She was likely the mom, maybe
unmarried. The patrolman helped me open her clothes. For pictures.
WHY?
Take off her clothes out in the open?
Remember, this was not just a crash. I investigated
a homicide. Had to check for other injuries like knife wounds, bullet wounds. I
shielded the victim from view. If it was daytime with a whole lot going on,
would’ve taken pictures in the morgue.
Okay.
Of course, makes sense. But, “Wild child”?
“Unmarried”? Why would you think that?
Well, she was really young. A lot of tattoos. It was 2:30 in the morning. She was ALONE.
She was really drunk. It wasn’t her car; it was registered to someone else –
possibly a parent. You put these things together. You get a sense. It doesn’t
mean I’m saying she’s a piece of shit!
I
DIDN’T, I... Go on.
Saw baby toys. It was sad. Baby lost its mother. I thought, what a shame.
The patrol guy and I worked together. Quietly. We opened Lauren up. Took
pictures. Someone held the sheet. When I did this part and had to speak, I
didn’t speak loudly. Spoke in hushed tones, really. Softly. Never spoke loudly.
It was rude. Didn’t know the victims but dying like that… It’s violent and
rude. Handled the victims gently, because they’ve reached their death and I
just wanted to be kind. Even if there was no life in them. You had to be,
what’s the word, sedate. Death is bad. Death is serious. Respectfully handled
her. Moved her slowly. Gave her a little dignity, you know.
Cleaned up the scene. Went to the registration
address. Nice neighborhood. Affluent. Guy who came to the door in his bathrobe
was her father. Dignified. Squared-away guy. Moneyed. When he saw us, his eyes
looked like he knew. I could see the woe, the pain. It was almost like he was
prepared. This moment had been coming. Behind him, I saw a baby walker, baby
things, scattered about. Felt a tug.
I asked to come in. His wife, from the top of the
stairs was hollering:
“What’s going
on? WHAT’S GOING ON?”
He led us to the kitchen. Mother was animated. He
calmed her down. She sat perched on his knee. Was curious but scared. She
leaned forward intently as we spoke. The patrol cop with me didn’t say a word.
It was all on me. As I spoke, mother got up. Paced. Finished up my spiel:
“Unfortunately, she succumbed to her
injuries…she did not survive.”
Never used the word dead. Too blunt. Hard. Never
used “morgue” either. The father’s eyes welled. I could be wrong…maybe he
looked relieved? Lauren’s demons had been quieted. The mother didn’t understand
what we were saying. Was wild-eyed.
“Where is she? We have to go to the hospital and be
with her! What does that mean? What does that mean?”
Her eyes searched the kitchen. Like she was looking
for her daughter. She also kept staring at the baby toys. Frantic. Her arms
were outstretched. Or on her head. Kept pacing in circles.
“What do you mean she DIDN’T survive?”
Father broke in loudly. Emotionally.
“It means she’s DEAD! DEAD!”
She slumped, all breath left her. Slid to the floor.
Let out a terrible sound like a deep moan. I’ve heard that moaning cry. A few
times. It’s awful. Awful sound. It’s the sound of losing your child. I stared at
the little child table in the corner. Red, blue, green. It’s weird how you
remember things like that.
You know,
when they cried like that, made that awful sound. They weren’t crying for the
now. They weren’t seeing their abusing, using daughter. The lost soul. They
were crying remembering their sweet two year old. Running around the garden
with pink bows on her hair. They saw her at her birthday party. Blowing
candles. They made those awful noises because…that was their baby. Gone. Forever.
We stayed longer. The father talked about his
daughter. Lauren was a wild child. They had put her in rehab. She got pregnant.
Moved back home. She got a job, was attempting to put her life back together.
She was trying.
As the father walked us to the door, he quietly
asked:
“Was she
drunk?”
Did
you give him the truth?
Told him there was some evidence of alcohol usage. Left
it at that. Why be brutal?
Did
you deal with them for a while? You know, help them out.
You know, heard back from families. They needed
closure. Answered questions. Gave guidance. Comforted. I was their connection to
their loved ones. Investigated their deaths. Fathers, mothers who couldn’t let
go would call. Cry. They were troubled. I listened, A LOT. Always felt that
listening was a part of my job. Least I could do. Had folks keep in contact for
years. They sent letters, cards, called.
But never heard from Lauren’s parents.
The
closure part. Can you tell me more about how families would find that closure?
There was the Marine father. His 17-year-old son
Andrew died. Tragic. An avoidable death. Andrew and two friends were in a Jeep,
speed was involved. On a hard stop Jeep rotated. Rolled over to the side. Wasn’t
belted. As the Jeep flopped over, he was partially ejected. As his body was
coming out, the Jeep roll bar landed on his head. Andrew was basically
decapitated. Head burst. Sprayed the inside of the Jeep.
What
happened to his friends?
Not a scratch.
Andrew’s father wasn’t available at the death
notification. In combat. Desert Storm? I
had no contact with him till he called a couple of days later. He wanted to get
some items from the Jeep. He and his son had worked on the Jeep together. Well,
the vehicle was bad. The firemen had taken the boy to the hospital. I don’t
know why, he wasn’t viable. He was headless, for Christ sake!
I
don‘t understand.
When somebody died on the scene, there were
contractors that came and gathered the pieces they found. But that night, the
firemen took a dead body to the hospital though there was no viability. They
were emotional, upset because he was a kid. They’re sensitive you know. They’re
a bunch of pussies. Anyhow, small pieces of Andrew got thrown back into the Jeep.
Like a hodge-podge of parts. On top of that, the inside was sprayed heavily.
With brain matter.
I told Andrew’s father on the phone that I’d get the
items for him. The man was coming over, period. He came. He was a colonel in the
Marine Corps. He was strack. Impeccable. Sharp uniform. Tall, striking, he
looked the part - a perfect commander of men. The real deal.
When he arrived he was ready to go, get the stuff.
As we were walking towards the back lot, I offered to collect the items again.
He wouldn’t have it. About 100 feet away from the vehicle, I stopped. I couldn’t
let him see the inside of that Jeep. There was brain, skin, hair. Blood. His
son. The odor.
“Colonel, I respect
the fact that you are a Marine. That you fight wars and see really bad things.
But you don’t want to see that Jeep. It is as bad as it gets. LET ME COLLECT
YOUR ITEMS”.
The colonel
appreciated the offer but said he was prepared. We headed to the car. About 50
feet away I turned to him.
“I’ll leave you here Colonel. Give you some privacy and
time. I’ll be back there, available. Just wave and I’ll come over”.
I walked away and turned. Colonel had reached the Jeep.
He groaned, grunted. Half fell to the ground, was on his knees. I ran to him. Helped
him up. He composed himself. After he
got himself together, his need was urgent.
“I’m getting cleaning supplies. I’ll be back to
clean up.”
“Colonel, we hire people that will take care of
that.”
“I don’t want anyone to see…this. Ever.”
He was back within the hour. He wore old clothes,
carried buckets, cleaners, tools. He took 2 hours to clean up his son’s
remains. I checked on him a couple of times, from afar. The Colonel paused at
times to collect himself. He wept as he cleaned. It was tough, really tough to
watch that. That was his boy. HIS boy.
(Long silence)
I’d like to wrap this up.
Jeff.
I’m sorry. So sorry. I didn’t realize how bad it was. How hard it was…for so
long. Sometimes you weren’t able to protect yourself, were you?
No, I live with it.
When I looked at the bodies, at Lauren, I thought of
you Rebecca. All that drinking. Years. That could have been you. I got lucky. When
I worked the young victims, the boys, I thought about our boys (puts hand on
chest). I’d think about how bad it would be to go to the house and tell you
that one of your sons had been killed (swallows).
Jeff.
I…I…